What Should You Ask a Digital Marketing Agency Before You Hire Them?
By Virtuance Digital Marketing · 22 November 2026

Before you hire a digital marketing agency, ask what business goal they will work towards, how they will report on progress, which channels they recommend and why, and who does what when AI is involved. A good agency answers plainly, in terms of your outcomes rather than their activity. Use the checklist below to compare agencies on the same footing.
What goals will the agency work towards?
Start with your goal, not their service list. An agency that jumps straight to "you need SEO, PPC and social" before asking what you are trying to achieve is selling, not advising.
Ask:
- What do you need to know about my business before recommending anything?
- How would you turn my goal (leads, sales, sign-ups, enquiries) into a target we can measure?
- What would you expect to be realistic in the first three months, and what takes longer?
A useful answer separates early signals, such as better-targeted traffic, from the results that follow later, such as more sales. Be wary of anyone who guarantees rankings or a fixed return before they have looked at your site, market or budget.
How will they report on results?
Reporting is where many agency relationships go wrong. Reports full of impressions and clicks can look busy while saying nothing about your business.
Ask to see a sample report and check:
- Does it link activity to your goals, such as enquiries or revenue, rather than only traffic?
- Will you get access to the underlying dashboards, or only a monthly PDF?
- How often will you meet, and who will explain the numbers?
- What happens when something is not working? How quickly is it flagged and changed?
A good report tells you what changed, why it matters and what happens next. If a result is bad, you should hear it from the agency first.
Which channels do they recommend, and why?
No single channel suits every business. Search engine optimisation, paid search, paid social, email, content and social media all do different jobs. Some bring steady growth over time; others produce faster, paid results that stop when the budget does. Our guide on SEO vs PPC explains the trade-off in more detail.
Ask the agency:
- Why these channels for my audience, and why not the others?
- How would you split the budget, and how would you decide when to move it?
- How do the channels work together, so that search, social and your website support one another?
The right answer is rooted in where your customers actually look and what they do before buying. If the proposal is the same one they would give any business, treat that as a warning.
How is the work split between AI and people?
Most agencies now use AI somewhere. That is not a problem in itself, but you should know where it is used and who checks it.
Ask:
- Which tasks are handled by AI tools, such as keyword research, budget allocation, forecasting or first drafts?
- Who reviews AI output before it reaches me or my customers?
- Who writes and approves content, and does it still sound like my brand?
- What do your people decide that software cannot?
Good answers describe a clear division. AI is typically strong at processing large amounts of data quickly; people are needed for strategy, judgement, tone and knowing what the numbers mean for your business. Virtuance Digital Marketing, for example, says it combines AI technology with marketing expertise and uses a hybrid of AI and human copywriting. Whichever agency you speak to, ask them to describe their own split in specific terms. For more on keeping a brand voice when using AI, see how to use AI for content creation without losing your brand voice.
Who owns the accounts, data and content?
This is easy to overlook until you want to leave. Ask:
- Will advertising accounts, analytics properties and website access be set up in my name?
- Who owns the content, creative and any reports produced?
- If we part ways, what do I take with me, and how is the handover handled?
- How do you handle customer data and consent? The UK regulator, the Information Commissioner's Office, is a good place to check the basics of data protection yourself.
You should keep control of your accounts and data. An agency confident in its work has no reason to make leaving difficult.
What evidence can they show?
Ask for case studies that resemble your situation, and look at what they actually describe. A strong case study states the problem, what was done, and the result, in plain terms.
- Was the problem similar to mine?
- What exactly did the agency do, as opposed to the client's own team?
- Can I speak to a past or current client?
- How long did results take?
Be cautious about vague claims such as "we doubled everything" without context. Ask what was measured, over what period, and compared with what.
How do you compare agencies fairly?
Give each agency the same brief and score their answers. A simple approach:
- Write down your goal, budget range and timeline, and send the same information to each agency.
- Ask the same core questions from this article.
- Score each answer on clarity, relevance to your business and honesty about limits.
- Note who asked you good questions in return.
- Check the contract: length, notice period, what is included and what costs extra.
The best fit is rarely the loudest pitch. It is the agency that understands your business, explains its reasoning without jargon and is straightforward about what it cannot promise.
What are the warning signs?
- Guaranteed rankings or results with no discussion of your market.
- Reluctance to share reports, access or accounts.
- A proposal that could have been written for anyone.
- Jargon used to avoid direct answers, especially about AI.
- Pressure to sign quickly.
- No clear person responsible for your account.
Frequently asked questions
How many agencies should I speak to?
Two or three is usually enough to compare approaches without becoming overwhelmed. Give each the same brief so the proposals are easy to compare.
Should I choose an agency that specialises in one channel or offers several?
It depends on your goal. A specialist can be a good choice if you know you need one thing, such as paid search. A broader agency can suit you if you want channels planned together. Either way, ask how the work is joined up with the rest of your marketing.
Is it a problem if an agency uses AI for content?
Not necessarily. The question is whether people review, edit and approve the work, and whether the result sounds like your business and is accurate. Ask the agency to explain its review process.
What should I prepare before the first call?
Write down your main goal, your current results if you have them, your target customers, any budget range and what has or has not worked before. This helps the agency give you a relevant answer rather than a generic pitch.
Next steps
If you would like to put these questions to Virtuance Digital Marketing, you can browse the services first and then get in touch by email at contact@virtuance.co.uk or by phone on +44 7852 620882.
Need help? Talk to Virtuance Digital Marketing
Get in touch
- Phone
- +44 7852 620882
